Skip to main content

The Civilizational Struggle: Why Democracy is an Unnatural State of Governance

 Why Democracy is a natural state of governance The Democratic Friction Democracy is frequently hailed as the pinnacle of human governance, built on the noble pillars of equality, liberty, and shared participation. However, a rigorous examination through the lenses of evolutionary psychology, history, and administrative efficiency suggests that democracy may actually be an unnatural state of governance. This perspective does not aim to dismiss democracy’s moral value but rather to highlight the inherent biological and sociological friction it creates within human societies. 1. The Biological Bias: Hierarchy vs. Egalitarianism For millions of years, human and pre-human ancestors lived in strictly hierarchical social structures. The Neurobiological Basis: Preference for social dominance hierarchies is linked to neural functioning in the brain's insula and anterior cingulate cortices , regions associated with social cognition and empathy. The Leadership Instinct : Biologically, ...
Post a Comment

Pros and cons of One Nation One Election

One Nation, One Election: A Path to Efficient Governance or a Federal Challenge?

A colorful map of India with national flags and "INDIA" text, representing the "One Nation, One Election" proposal to synchronize national and state voting


The concept of One Nation, One Election (ONOE) is no longer just a theoretical debate in India; it is a proposed structural reform to synchronise elections for the Lok Sabha and all state legislative assemblies. As India moves toward 2026, the discussion around simultaneous elections has intensified, focusing on whether a unified electoral calendar can fix a governance system currently trapped in a "perpetual campaign mode."

For a nation striving for rapid economic growth and scientific literacy, understanding the massive financial and administrative drain of frequent elections is crucial.

The Hidden Cost of Perpetual Elections

One of the strongest arguments for ONOE is the staggering amount of resources consumed by the current "staggered" system.

1. The Financial Burden: Billions Spent on Ballots

In the 2024 Lok Sabha elections, estimates suggest a total expenditure of nearly ₹1.35 lakh crore ($16 billion). This figure includes both government spending and the massive outlays by political parties.

  • Government Costs: Thousands of crores are spent on logistics, EVMs, and the deployment of millions of polling staff.

  • Party Spending: High-frequency elections force parties to constantly raise funds, often leading to a reliance on "socio-economic toxicity" and populist freebies to win quick votes.

2 The Time Drain: Politics Over Policy

Perhaps the most damaging cost is the time and effort of our leaders. In the current system, India is almost always in an election cycle.

  • The Campaign Trap: Prime Ministers, Chief Ministers, and Union Cabinet Ministers spend months every year away from their desks, flying across states to address rallies. Instead of focusing on policy implementation or national security, the nation's top brains are often preoccupied with "winning the next district."

  • Policy Paralysis: The Model Code of Conduct (MCC) comes into force every time an election is announced. This halts the launch of new developmental schemes, freezes capital expenditure, and slows down the administrative machinery for months at a time. ONOE would restrict this disruption to once every five years.


Pros: Why ONOE Could Transform India

Optimized Governance Efficiency

By synchronizing cycles, the government can shift its focus from "electoral survival" to long-term governance. This allows for the implementation of complex reforms in sectors like manufacturing and aerospace—areas vital for India's global standing—without the fear of immediate electoral backlash.

Resource and Security Management

Currently, hundreds of thousands of Central Armed Police Forces (CAPF) are moved across the country year-round for election duty. This creates a security vacuum in sensitive border areas. ONOE would allow for a one-time deployment, ensuring our military and police resources are better utilized for national defense.

Boosting the Economy

Finance experts suggest that simultaneous elections could add up to 1.5% to India's GDP growth. By reducing the "black money" circulation common during frequent polls and ensuring a stable policy environment, ONOE creates a more predictable landscape for both domestic and international investors.

Cons: The Challenges of Implementation

Constitutional and Legal Hurdles

Implementing ONOE requires amending at least five articles of the Constitution. It also raises questions about what happens if a state government falls mid-term. Would the entire country go to polls again, or would the state have a "truncated" term?

The Risk to Regional Identity

Critics argue that national issues might overshadow regional concerns. In a simultaneous election, a "national wave" could lead to the marginalisation of regional parties that focus on problems localised like state-specific cultural reform or local infrastructure

Logistical Mammoth

India’s voter base is nearly 970 million. Holding elections for the center and all states at once would require a massive increase in the number of EVMs and VVPAT machines, alongside a historic level of logistical coordination across diverse terrains.

Conclusion: Balancing Efficiency with Democracy

The One Nation, One Election proposal offers a solution to the "perpetual election" fatigue that drains India’s wealth and leadership energy. While the logistical and federal challenges are real, the potential to free up our leaders for actual nation-building—rather than constant campaigning—is an opportunity India may need to take to reach its 2047 goals.

As we debate this reform, the focus must remain on ensuring that while we gain efficiency, we do not lose the vibrancy of our regional voices.

Labels:

Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

From Opposite Ends to Converging Paths: Wokeism and Fascism are the same

 Are Wokeism and Fascism two faces of the same demon? Introduction: Woke and Fascist Logic What does this woke and Fascist ideology mean? In today's socio-political landscape, the ideologies of Wokeism and Fascism have emerged as prominent forces, often perceived as polar opposites. However, a deeper examination reveals striking similarities between the two. This article explores the convergence of Wokeism and Fascism, shedding light on their shared characteristics, tactics, and societal impacts. Understanding Wokeism Defining Wokeism : Wokeism, a term derived from "stay woke," refers to a social awareness movement that emphasizes identifying and combating societal injustices, particularly t hose related to race, gender, and identity. Woke Origins and Evolution Wokeism traces its roots to various civil rights movements and academic theories, evolving over time to encompass a wide range of progressive ideologies. mostly it is derived from left-leaning ideology Core Tenets ...
Post a Comment
Read more

What is the of USAID: Its Mission, Impact, and Challenges" And its potential Shutdown

  Understanding USAID and Its Role in Global Development The United States Agency for International Development (USAID) is a critical entity in global development, aimed at advancing economic development , democracy , and human rights around the world. Over the years, USAID has been involved in providing financial aid , expertise, and resources to developing countries to improve health, education, governance, and other critical sectors. 1. What Does USAID Do? USAID is responsible for providing foreign aid to promote sustainable development, improve living standards, and assist in humanitarian crises. It focuses on a wide range of issues such as poverty alleviation , disaster relief , health initiatives (including combating HIV/AIDS ), and education . Additionally, USAID supports programs aimed at building good governance and promoting economic growth in countries around the world. 2. USAID Budget and how it's allocated around the world  USAID’s budget is allocated to v...
Post a Comment
Read more

Why budget of 2025 is a 'Make' or 'Break' budget for India ? A deep dive why India's economy is suffering and its solutions

 Why 2025 Budget is a "Make or Break" moment for India India is taking a significant turn as it prepares for the Union budget in 2025 . The country's economic scenario includes high taxes, populist politics, and a government that often prioritizes choice success over meaningful governance. These factors raise an important question: Will the budget in 2025 put India on the road to long-term economic development, or will it elaborate on the existing challenges? Citizens have set high expectations over this budget especially working class and small to medium size business owners as they are the ones who get scrutinised the most due to high taxation and indirect taxation like GST ( goods and service tax). As the Fast-growing economy tends to slow its growth from 8.4 % to 6.3% India's aspiration to become develop the economy by 2047 seems a difficult task to achieve. to mark this milestone India needs at least Two decades of growth around 8% to 9% only then it will be able...
Post a Comment
Read more